About the blog

This is blog features a collection of short articles by V. Premnath.

The articles try to compile some of the thoughts, suggestions and ideas that I have shared with young people who have approached me for advise.

This blog is connected to the website, www.premnath.org

You can write to Premnath at v.premnath(at)ncl.res.in

Recent Posts

(12 Oct 2018) Open Innovation: Excerpts from CII CTO Summit

On 12 Oct 2018, CII ran a CTO Summit at Taj Palace, Mumbai with a focus on Open Innovation. I moderated a session on IP Strategy for Open Innovation. Good to see the CTO Forum of CII come up with such relevant themes.


For those new to the topic, see a short introduction at http://www.openinnovation.eu/open-innovation/

My panel focused on IP strategy for Open Innovation.


Some points from the panel :

Interestingly, the patent system was created when inventors were encouraged by the kings to disclose their ideas (so that society would not loose the invention along with the inventors when they die) in exchange for a period of time when they could prevent others from copying their ideas. The whole idea was to “open” out the invention for larger social good while ensuring that the inventors are given some time to secure some rewards for their creativity.

Open innovation takes “open” to a new extreme. In my view, open innovation may actually reshape the IP profession in entirely new ways by posing the most complex and largest challenges for IP professionals in the coming years. With no single entity being able to fund all aspects of the innovation process or control the entire innovation ecosystem, collaboration is inevitable. More importantly, the complexity of the collaboration process is bound to increase many folds — with multiple partners (such as large companies, startups, academia, individuals etc) all vying for a share of the rewards. The frameworks which will enable such interactions will invariably be open innovation frameworks and the key enablers will be open innovation architects.

IP strategy in open innovation will invariably require greater trust between multiple partners. This will mean that the leadership at the highest levels will have to get involved in initiating open innovation programs. It will be necessary to keep the focus on the larger goals and objectives and not get bogged down by policies, procedures, existing power structures etc. Champions of open innovation programs will have to push for a culture change which understands limitations of closed innovation and encourages open innovation strategically. The anchor entities in any open innovation program will often need to be generous in sharing rewards with smaller partners. Companies will need to think deeply about which innovation programs they wish to pursue in open innovation mode and which innovations in closed innovation mode. Companies will need to do some deep thinking on what is the core of their business and what is the periphery. Companies will need to carry out intense technology foresight exercises to define the roadmap for the future. Companies will need to rethink their policies and strategies on IP ownership and rights. As multiple partners will each jostle for a greater share of rewards, companies will need to creatively rethink their models of risk-reward sharing, rights and responsibilities in collaborations and how they control the advancement of technology towards the market. Companies will need to rethink their philosophies around confidentiality and evolve ways to firewall and insulate open innovation and closed innovation programs.

We can learn more by studying some cases where open innovation seems to work well:

  • Open innovation seems to work well when all partners are working towards a socially important goal. These goals encourage people to put their private interests into the back burner and focus on doing well for society. And this simplifies the complexity in the agreements and understanding between parties. Several open source and open access initiatives fall under this category. An effort to develop drugs for neglected diseases or a diagnostic for reducing misuse of antibiotics or an open source bionic arm project etc will fall under this category.
  • Open innovation seems to work well when a group of entities are collaborating to build a common ecosystem or platform which will be a public good or social good on which they can then build their private goods. This could include base level platform technologies, industry standards etc. An example would be EV companies collaborating on building battery technologies so that advancements in battery technologies could help their own EV businesses to flourish.
  • Open innovation seems to also work well when companies collaborate to build technologies against a common threat. For example, companies at different parts of the plastics value chain collaborating to develop plastic waste management solutions so as to contest possible bans on plastic by governments.

It is clear that companies that can master open innovation strategies and make them work to their advantage will gain tremendously in the future.

  1. (2 Sep 2018) My memories of my grandfather Comments Off
  2. (11 Aug 2018) Convocation address, Dept of Chem Engg, IIT-Bombay Comments Off
  3. (25 June 2018) Selected reports on startups and VC investments in India Comments Off
  4. (25 June 2018) Selected Readings on Incubation and Acceleration Comments Off
  5. (20 May 2018) Interesting comments in Blink article on Memes Comments Off
  6. (22 April 2018) New book on Med Tech Innovation by Prof Ravi, IIT-Bombay Comments Off
  7. (20 April 2018) Dr Padmanabhan’s new memoir Comments Off
  8. (20 April 2018) Using Rallly for scheduling meetings involving multiple busy people: Comments Off
  9. (21 July 2017) Learning from Ashish Comments Off
  10. (10 June 2017) Mission Admission — A reality check! Comments Off
  11. Excerpts from “Shoe Dog: A memoir by the creator of Nike” by Phil Knight. Comments Off
  12. Defining technology, innovation, entrepreneurship, social entrepreneurship! Comments Off
  13. (2 June 2016) Success is defined by your choices Comments Off
  14. Why do we work? Comments Off
  15. How can startups attract and retain talent? Comments Off
  16. Career development: Growing in responsibilities Comments Off
  17. Tips for writing a Statement of Purpose (SOP) Comments Off
  18. Does poor academic performance in school/college matter to my prospects? Comments Off
  19. Quotes from “I too had a dream”, by Verghese Kurien Comments Off
  20. Tips on writing good resumes Comments Off
  21. How to choose a company name (in India)? Comments Off
  22. Careers in intellectual property in India Comments Off
  23. On social enterprises Comments Off
  24. What is entrepreneurship? Comments Off
  25. How should you choose a place to pursue undergraduate studies? Comments Off
  26. Seeking a job vs seeking excellence Comments Off
  27. How do US universities decide on who to admit for PhD programs and offer scholarships? Comments Off
  28. No absolutes Comments Off
  29. Fire in the belly Comments Off
  30. The curse of versatility Comments Off
  31. The opportunity in front of chemical engineers today Leave a reply
  32. What is Chemical engineering? Leave a reply
  33. What is science? What motivates scientists? Leave a reply
  34. Should you join a PhD program? Leave a reply
  35. Competition and blinders Comments Off
  36. Learning goals for primary school children Comments Off
  37. Launch of the blog Comments Off